This the tale of two reviews. First Date was amusing. First Date was cute. First Date was everything a delightful, off-Broadway show for $40 a ticket should be. Trouble is, it's on Broadway. Tickets are up there at $100/ticket for a mere 90 minutes if you're not savvy enough to find a discount. While it's cute, it's not all-that.
Don't get me wrong, I giggled and even laughed out loud a few times, but the material seemed amateurish. The music was upbeat, but not very memorable. Tourist-formulaic come to mind. Funny; Short enough to hold their attention; Hip enough to be cool. The acting was OK, but it just seemed like a good off-Broadway show.
Zachary Levy was adorable and dreamy. Krista Rodriguez was her cold-hearted SMASH self. These are the characters they played. This is who they always seem to play. Kristoffer Cusick (Reggie) stole the show with his Bailout Song - repeatedly.
I left with a smile wondering if it will last and if the tourists will keep rolling in. Probably so. That Zachary Levy is adorable. No way he's really single.